Back Nutley NJ in the early 60s OMG, i would eat both boxes! Who knew that by adding hot cocoa mix to a cookie batter you’d get such a delicious tasting cookie? Chocolate Sandwich Cookies that are rich and chewy with a creamy marshmallow filling just like from your favorite bakery! It was a soft cookie sandwich (the outside cookie looked like social tea cookies but were soft) with jelly marmalade inside and chocolate sprinkles on the outside of the jelly in between the soft cookies. To the best of my memory, the cookie she made tastes exactly like the original. Soft marshmallow gently pressed between two soft vanilla wafers. They were the BEST ever!!!!!!!! READ WHAT I HAVE TO WRITE: I lived in the Bronx until 1990 and remember buying them in a Finefare supermarket on the Grand Concourse in 1989 at the latest, and I believe quite possibly, although I'm not 100% sure, in early 1990 as well. Last time they were sold was on the Lower East Side at the Economy Candy store and there was a more commercialized version that was completely covered in chocolate that sold in supermarkets in NYC. That's all I can say!!! They are incredible! Make a petition...I'd sign!! They are not spell checked or reviewed for accuracy. By the way, FDNY343 is right on the money with his description! He said they also made a peanut butter coated and filled one. But SO WORTH IT. Memories:), My grandmother would send these to me when I was overseas back in the 70's. I've been trying to figure out for years what those cookies were called and if I could still get them! The following are comments left about Nabisco Marshmallow Cookies from site visitors such as yourself. google_ad_height = 600; Someone has to organize the Baby Boomers to get it going to bring them back. Get the recipe for Gingerbread Puffs. 9 Review(s) 5 Min(s) 5 Min(s) Prep. Would love to see them on the supermarket shelves again! Come on "Boomers" send your requests to NABISCO: "Bring back the our cookie!!". I was actually dreaming of these cookies last night! Let me show you another Christmas Cookie … Dress up some vanilla wafers with peanut butter and marshmallow creme to make yummy sandwich cookies. Have friends whom own supermarkets and we would love to bring this delicious taste back home to Brooklyn nyttes. !please bring them back nabisco !!!!! I agree. The following are links about Nabisco Marshmallow Cookies you may find interesting. The cookie part was NOT a vanilla wafer. The best is when you got them fresh. They were like the Vanilla wafers but softer. 1 teaspoon vanilla. Was there also a cookkie with a dab of jelly in the middle near the top...? CHOCOLATE-MARSHMALLOW COOKIES. I was looking for a sweet and salty dessert idea and came across these chocolate marshmallow cookies. google_ad_format = "120x600_as"; I wish they would bring these back... i want the nabisco marshmallow sandwich cookies... loved them can i still get them??? Please bring back the marshmellow sandwich cookie, so many people are asking for this. First, a child was taken into a room and allowed to pick a snack that they would like to eat, such as a marshmallow, a pretzel, or a cookie. The recipe that I always follow comes from a slight variation of the Original NESTLÉ®TOLLHOUSE® Chocolate Chip Cookie recipe.That recipe is a really good recipe to follow. You can still buy those from supermarkets. When the gauge is full, the parade begins! OMG my mouth waters, would love to taste that again..C'mon Nabisco? A little grocery store on Court St. and First Place, Georgies. WOW! Every time I walk down the alse for cookies I look for Nabisco Marshmellow cookie in the blue box. 1¾ cups flour google_ad_client = "pub-1475700848612418"; google_ad_type = "text_image"; Nabisco brings out Mallomars for 6 months, can't they bring these back for a few months too. I've been looking on the internet for years with just a few sites with these stories. For bonus points, roll 'em in chopped peanuts. OOH, I LOVED the Nabisco Marshmallow Sandwich Cookies!! Submit a link to more information about Nabisco Marshmallow Cookies. How do you think about the answers? //2007-06-05: inthe70s My whole family LOVED these cookies. I'm glad to see that so many others loved them too. Marshmallow cookies are soft and chewy chocolate chip cookies loaded with gooey marshmallows! this takes me back, I loved those cookies and what was even more special is that as a child born in 1981 I used to leave these cookies out for Santa every xmas until they stop making them. 6 servings. Please bring these back still to this day I look on the shelves hoping they brought them back. This holiday classic is so easy, festive and fun! Soft marshmallow gently pressed between two soft vanilla wafers. I have been looking for years!! During the parade, the Sugar Guards go forward and create March Jellies. pleeease bring them back!! JUST LIKE THE OLD ADAGE STATES , " DON'T CUT YOUR NOSE OFF TO SPITE YOUR FACE " SO PLEASE BE SENSIBLE , AND BRING BACK THIS " ICONIC " COOKIE . google_color_bg = "E7F0EB"; It wasn't made by Nabisco, but rather by a small, local chocolate company. When it comes to holiday baking, I love making English toffee , pecan pie bars , and these gooey marshmallow cookies . I would LOVE to see the marshmallow sandwich, melody and chocolate snaps return to the market! My dad is trying to remember the name of a cookie from the late 50s early 60s. With a few changes, however, these gingerbread puffs now have a soft, moist texture, with the added pleasure of making good use of leftover mashed potatoes. Still have questions? !Why cant you make them a seasonal item??? The marshmallow is half pink, half white, as is the packet they come in. Came in two long boxes with blue wrapper on it . I have been searching for these cookies for years!! Submit a story or info about Nabisco Marshmallow Cookies,